DuHocNuocNgoai.comDu Học Nước Ngoài
Student visas

US, UK, Australia, Canada and Germany student visas compared: assessment, work rights, staying on

The US relies heavily on the interview, the UK on technical criteria, Australia and Canada assess the application as a whole, and Germany filters early through APS. A comparison of assessment, work rights, dependants and post-study options.

US, UK, Australia, Canada and Germany student visas compared: assessment, work rights, staying on

The five countries most often chosen by Vietnamese students assess visas in five different ways: the US focuses on the interview and intention to return; the UK relies heavily on technical criteria such as the CAS, the financial threshold and the number of days funds are held; Australia and Canada assess the application as a whole on paper, with Australia's Genuine Student requirement and Canada's assessment of the purpose of the visit; Germany filters early through the APS certificate and the blocked account. Part-time work rights and post-graduation routes also differ, and changed significantly over 2023–2025.

This article does not rank any country as "easy" or "hard", because difficulty depends on each person's application: an application that is strong on paper but belongs to a student who is shy about speaking may do better in a country that assesses documents; a complicated financial file presented well by the student may do better where there is an interview. The aim is to help you see what each system assesses, so you can choose a country and prepare in the right places. Details for each country are in the country sections of this site.

Overview table of the five systems

The information below follows the regulations published at the time of writing. Immigration policy changes frequently; always check each country's official website before deciding.

CriterionUSUKAustraliaCanadaGermany
Visa nameF-1StudentSubclass 500Study permitNational visa for study
Enrolment documentI-20CASCoELOA (+ PAL/TAL for most applications)Admission letter + APS
Main assessment methodInterview, 214(b)Technical criteria + genuine studentPaper application, Genuine StudentPaper application, holistic assessmentPaper application, possible interview
Financial mechanismBased on the costs on the I-20Balance held for the required number of daysMinimum living costs published by AustraliaPublished minimum, with a GIC optionBlocked account
Part-time work during termOn campus up to 20 hours/week20 hours/week (degree level and above)48 hours per fortnight24 hours/week off campus140 full days or 280 half days/year
Staying on after studyOPT 12 months, STEM OPT a further 24 monthsGraduate RouteSubclass 485 visaPGWPJob-seeker permit of up to 18 months

Each cell in the table is a large topic with many conditions attached. For example, the UK's work entitlement is 20 hours for degree level and above and lower for courses below that; Canada's PGWP has field-of-study conditions for some programmes. Read the detailed article for each country before doing your calculations.

How they assess: interview, technical or holistic

The US system places the decision in the hands of a consular officer after a short interview. The advantage: the paperwork does not need to be perfect if the student presents well. The disadvantage: the outcome depends heavily on a few minutes, and the burden of proving non-immigrant intent lies with the applicant. Confident students who speak clearly about their plans can often play to their strengths here.

The UK system is technical: with a valid CAS, enough money at the right level for the right number of days and the required language standard, most applications go through; the main risks are technical errors and credibility interviews for applications selected for them. It is the most "predictable" system if you follow the rules exactly, but it does not tolerate small mistakes.

Australia and Canada assess the application as a whole on paper, with few interviews. The study plan, the reasons for choosing the course and the explanation of finances carry a lot of weight. Australia also sets processing priority by education provider, so the choice of institution directly affects the visa application. Since 2024 Canada has had a cap on study permits and requires a provincial attestation letter for most applications, and it ended the SDS fast-track stream in November 2024.

Germany filters early: the APS certificate checks the authenticity and quality of Vietnamese qualifications before you apply to institutions, and the blocked account secures finances through a fixed mechanism. Once these steps are done, the visa application is usually more procedural, but appointments can be a bottleneck.

Finances: five mechanisms, one principle

US. Prove that you can cover the costs stated on the I-20, at least for the first year, and that you can pay for later years. There is no hard rule on how long funds must be held, but the source of the money is asked about at the interview.

UK. Outstanding first-year tuition plus a monthly living cost amount (different for London and outside London), a balance held for the required number of consecutive days, and a bank statement that is not too old. The rules are clear, and being one day short can lead to refusal.

Australia. The minimum living cost for twelve months published by Australia, plus tuition and travel; this can be shown through deposits, loans, scholarships or parents' income in the accepted forms.

Canada. The published minimum for living costs plus first-year tuition; many people choose a GIC because it is easy to prove, but the source of funds is still assessed as a whole.

Germany. A blocked account holding the amount set each year, from which only a fixed sum can be withdrawn each month. The mechanism is rigid but transparent.

Work rights and accompanying family

Work rights during term range from very limited (US: mainly on campus, up to 20 hours a week; off-campus work only in authorised categories such as CPT and OPT) to relatively flexible (Australia: 48 hours per fortnight; Canada: 24 hours a week off campus from November 2024; Germany: 140 full days or 280 half days a year). The UK allows 20 hours a week during term for degree level and above. No country designs its work rights to cover all your costs; your financial plan should not depend on them.

Accompanying family members are a major difference for postgraduate students who are married. From January 2024 the UK does not allow most international students to bring dependants, except students on research-based postgraduate programmes. Canada narrowed the categories of spouses eligible for an open work permit from 2024, focusing on master's and doctoral students and certain professional programmes. The US allows dependants to come on F-2 status but they may not work. Australia still allows dependants in many cases, with additional financial requirements. These rules change quickly; check carefully before planning for the whole family.

Staying on after graduation: each country has its own design

US — OPT. Practical training for up to 12 months after graduation, with a further 24-month extension for STEM fields. Staying longer requires switching to a work category such as the H-1B, which has a quota and a lottery.

UK — Graduate Route. Allows you to stay and work after completing your programme without an employer sponsor; the current length is two years for bachelor's and master's graduates and three years for doctoral graduates. The immigration white paper of May 2025 announced a plan to shorten it to 18 months — check the effective date on the official website.

Australia — subclass 485 visa. Streams by level of study; the length has been shortened and the age limit lowered from July 2024. Conditions on English language and time studied in Australia apply.

Canada — PGWP. The length depends on the length of the programme, up to three years; from November 2024, students in some college programmes must study a field on the labour shortage list, and there is a language requirement. The institution must be a PGWP-eligible DLI.

Germany — job-seeker permit. Up to 18 months after graduation to look for work that matches your qualification, with unrestricted work allowed during this time. Once you find a job, you switch to the appropriate work permit.

Major changes in 2023–2025 you need to know

A lot of study abroad information passed by word of mouth, including on advisory websites, is still based on rules from before 2024. The list below summarises the changes that have been announced; details and effective dates should be checked on the official websites.

  • Australia: the GTE requirement was replaced by Genuine Student from March 2024; the minimum financial requirement increased; the 485 visa was adjusted from July 2024; the way applications are prioritised by education provider changed.
  • Canada: a cap on study permits and provincial attestation letters from January 2024; the minimum financial requirement increased; field-of-study conditions for the PGWP and a 24-hour work limit from November 2024; the SDS stream ended.
  • UK: dependants restricted for most students from January 2024; the living cost amount to be proven increased; a plan to shorten the Graduate Route was announced.
  • Germany: work rights extended to 140 full days or 280 half days a year under the amended skilled immigration law; the blocked account amount is adjusted every year.
  • US: from 2025, interview waivers were narrowed, applicants are required to apply in their country of nationality or residence, and student visa applicants are required to make the social media accounts declared on the form public.

Information that is two years old may be completely wrong. When you read any guide, including articles on this site, check the date it was written and compare it with official sources.

Choosing a country based on your own visa profile

Instead of asking "which country has the easiest visa", ask "where is my application strong, where is it weak, and which system values those strengths". A student with good grades, good language skills and a family with a clear income, but who is uncomfortable speaking, may find the UK, Australia and Canada more favourable. A confident student who presents well but whose financial file has many sources that are hard to document may find the US interview a chance to explain in person.

Budget is also a visa factor: Germany has low public tuition fees but requires a large blocked sum upfront; the UK requires the balance to be held exactly according to the rules; Canada and Australia require the published minimum. Families with substantial assets but little readily available cash need to allow time to convert them before applying.

Post-graduation goals should be considered from the start, but they should not be the only reason for choosing a country, because policies on staying change faster than a course lasts. Choose a country for the programme and your ability to adapt, and treat the right to stay as a bonus, not the main goal.

Frequently asked questions

Which country has the highest student visa approval rate for Vietnamese applicants?

Countries do not publish figures in the same way, and an overall rate says nothing about the chances of a particular application. A strong application can be approved in any country; a weak one can be refused in a country thought to be easy. Choose a country based on the programme and how well your application fits, not on rates passed around by word of mouth.

Does a visa refusal from one country affect applications to another?

Yes, to the extent that you must declare it, because most visa forms ask about refusals from any country. One refusal does not automatically mean you will be refused elsewhere, but the officer may look at the reason. The right approach is to declare it honestly and show that the new application has addressed the weaknesses.

Can international students work as soon as they arrive?

It depends on the country. Australia, Canada and the UK allow part-time work from when the course starts, within the set hour limits. The US allows on-campus work; off-campus work requires an authorised category such as CPT, usually after one year of study. Japan requires a permit to engage in activity outside the status of residence.

Can you switch from a student visa to a work visa in these countries?

Yes, through each country's post-study and skilled work categories. Each country has its own conditions on field, salary and language, and policies change frequently. A student visa does not guarantee the right to switch; treat it as a possibility, not a promise.

Why does Canada require a provincial attestation letter?

Since 2024 Canada has set a cap on the number of study permits and allocated it among the provinces. The provincial attestation letter (PAL or TAL) shows that the application falls within that allocation. Some groups, such as school-age students and some postgraduate levels, may be exempt according to each year's rules.

Does a scholarship help a visa application?

Yes. A scholarship reduces the financial burden you have to prove, and a prestigious scholarship is also evidence of academic ability and a clear purpose of study. Some government scholarships come with a commitment to return, which creates an additional tie. State the value and conditions of the scholarship clearly in your application.

Need specific advice for your case?

We will contact you within 24 hours.

Request consultation now

Related articles

Need more help?

Leave your details and we will get back to you within 24 hours.