DuHocNuocNgoai.comDu Học Nước Ngoài
After graduation and settling

Guaranteed immigration services and buying job sponsorship: the risks international students need to recognise

Paying for sponsorship, courses taken only to keep a visa, fake job offers: the real risks after graduation, what each country's law says, and how to check an immigration adviser.

Guaranteed immigration services and buying job sponsorship: the risks international students need to recognise

The period after graduation is when international students are most open to exploitation: work rights are about to run out, the pressure to stay is high, and there is always someone offering "guaranteed immigration" or selling a job sponsorship place. In many countries, paying in exchange for visa sponsorship is against the law — Australia prohibits asking for or receiving payment in return for an immigration outcome, the UK prohibits sponsors from passing sponsorship costs on to workers, and Canada prohibits employers from recovering the cost of the labour market impact assessment from workers. People who pay do not only lose money; they may also lose their visa and carry a mark on their immigration history.

The rules for protecting yourself are simple: nobody can guarantee an immigration authority's decision; anyone who charges for immigration advice must be registered and listed in an official register; and any job offer that comes with a request for money should be treated with suspicion. This article goes through the common types of risk, what each country's law says in principle, and how to check before you trust anyone.

Common types of risk after graduation

Buying a sponsorship place. An "employer" or intermediary offers to sponsor a work visa or nominate you for permanent residence on condition that you pay a large sum, sometimes along with working unpaid or paying back part of your salary every month. This is explicitly prohibited in many countries, and when it is discovered both sides can face penalties.

Fake job offers. A professional-looking offer, sent from an email address that closely resembles a real company's name, asks you to pay an "application processing" fee, "insurance" or a "compulsory training course" before you start. Real companies do not charge the people they hire in order to give them a job.

Courses taken only to keep a visa. When work rights are about to expire, some people enrol in cheap, low-quality courses just to get a new student visa and stay on. Countries have cracked down hard on this; applications that move down to a lower level of study or chain several unrelated courses are easily refused and may be treated as not genuinely studying.

"Guaranteed immigration" services. Packages that promise a result, refund you if you are refused, or claim "connections" in the immigration authority. Nobody controls a government's decision; a guarantee is a warning sign, not a sign of credibility.

False information in applications. Work experience that has been "embellished", salary letters that do not reflect reality, a sham marriage to go as a dependant. Fraud, once discovered, can lead to a ban on applying for many years, and that mark follows the applicant into applications in other countries.

What some countries' laws say about paying for sponsorship

The table summarises principles from published rules; it is not legal advice. Details and specific penalties should be read on the official websites or checked with a registered adviser.

CountryPrinciplePossible consequences
AustraliaProhibits asking for, receiving, offering or giving money or benefits in return for sponsorship, nomination or employment linked to a visaCivil and criminal penalties for those in breach; the visa holder involved may have their visa cancelled
United KingdomSponsors must pay the certificate of sponsorship fee and the immigration skills charge themselves and may not pass them on to the workerThe sponsor can lose its sponsor licence; the worker can lose the basis for their visa
CanadaEmployers may not recover the cost of the labour market impact assessment from the worker; buying or selling job offers to gain points or a permit is fraudEmployers are fined and banned from hiring foreign workers; the applicant may be found to have made a misrepresentation
United StatesEmployers may not pass certain H-1B work visa fees on to the worker; they must pay the required wageEmployers are fined and must refund; applications showing signs of fraud are investigated

The common thread: these countries treat sponsorship as the employer's responsibility and cost, in return for getting the worker they need. An "employer" who asks you to pay to be sponsored is turning that principle upside down.

Registered immigration advisers: how to check in five minutes

In countries that take many international students, paid immigration advice is a regulated profession. In Australia, migration agents must be registered with the migration agents registration authority and have a registration number you can look up; practising lawyers may also give advice. In Canada, immigration consultants must be members of the regulatory body for immigration and citizenship consultants, or be lawyers, or notaries in Quebec. In the UK, immigration advisers must be authorised by the immigration advice regulator (formerly known as the OISC) or belong to a regulated legal profession. In New Zealand, immigration advisers need a licence from the immigration advisers authority. In the US, only lawyers or accredited representatives of organisations recognised by the Department of Justice may represent people in immigration matters.

How to check: ask for the registration or membership number, then look it up yourself in the regulator's official register — not through a link the person sends you. Check the name, place of practice, whether the registration is current, and any disciplinary history if the register publishes it. Someone who refuses to give a registration number, or says "we work through a partner over there", is a reason to stop.

Registered advisers usually have to sign a service agreement that sets out the scope of work, professional fees kept separate from government charges, and what happens if the client wants to stop. Read the agreement carefully, keep a copy, and pay into an account in the name of the practice rather than a personal account.

In Vietnam, many study abroad agencies do a good job of choosing universities, preparing academic applications and student visas; but permanent residence and work visa applications in the host country should be handled by someone registered in that country, because they are professionally accountable to the regulator where you apply.

Signs that you should stop and ask more questions

No single sign proves a scam on its own, but if you see two or more, stop all payments and check again from the beginning.

  • A promise of a visa or settlement outcome, or a refund if you are refused, presented as a guarantee.
  • A request for payment to be hired, sponsored or nominated; or a request to pay back part of your salary once you start work.
  • A job offer without a real interview, sent from a free email address or a domain that closely resembles a real company.
  • Pressure to decide quickly: "only one place left", "the policy is about to close, you must pay this week".
  • A suggestion to give false information, "embellish" your experience or salary, or borrow documents from another company.
  • No clear service agreement, no invoices, cash only or transfers to a personal account.
  • An adviser with no registration you can look up in the country where the application will be made.

When in doubt, universities all have an international student office and legal advice services for students, usually free. The immigration authorities and consumer protection bodies in these countries have channels for reporting scams.

If you have already paid or submitted a problematic application

The first thing is to stop any further payments and keep all the evidence: messages, emails, contracts, transfer receipts, the name of the receiving account. The more complete the evidence, the better the chance of recovering money or having the matter dealt with.

Next, get independent advice from a registered adviser or your university's legal service to understand your current visa status and your options. If an application you submitted contains false information, the best course is usually to clarify it proactively with the immigration authority following your adviser's guidance, rather than waiting to be found out. Each country has its own procedures, and the consequences of coming forward are usually lighter than those of being discovered.

Reporting to the authorities helps not only you but also those who come after you. In many countries, workers who are exploited or asked to pay for sponsorship are protected when they report it, and there are arrangements so that they do not lose their visa just for reporting an employer in breach. Find out about these arrangements through worker support organisations or your university's legal service.

Taking the long road, cleanly

The legal route to staying is usually slower and nothing is guaranteed, but every right step adds up: real experience, better language, a clean immigration history, a professional network. Even if you do not stay in the end, all of these keep their value when you return to Vietnam or move to another country. A record of fraud does the opposite: it follows the person into every future visa application, including tourist visas.

For families, the most important advice is not to let the pressure to "stay at all costs" push your child into risky choices. A timely decision to come home, with real experience, is far better than a large sum paid for a promise nobody can keep.

Global Gate Pass provides study abroad advice — choosing universities and programmes with post-study work rights in mind, preparing academic and student visa applications — and does not sell guaranteed immigration services. If your family is weighing up an offer and would like an independent second opinion, you can book a free first session to go through the terms together.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to pay a company to sponsor your visa?

In many countries it is not. Australia prohibits asking for or receiving money in return for sponsorship or employment linked to a visa; the UK prohibits sponsors from passing sponsorship costs on to workers; Canada prohibits employers from recovering the cost of the labour market assessment procedure. The person who pays may have their visa affected.

How can you tell whether an immigration adviser is registered?

Ask for the registration or membership number, then look it up yourself in the official register of the immigration advice regulator in that country, without using a link the person sends you. Check the name, whether the registration is current, and any disciplinary history if it is published.

Is there any service that can guarantee immigration?

No. Decisions on visas and permanent residence belong to the government of the host country. A registered adviser can only assess your chances and prepare the application correctly; a guaranteed result is a warning sign.

Can you enrol in another course to stay after your work rights end?

In principle you can apply for a new student visa if you are genuinely going to study, but countries look closely at moves to a lower level or chains of unrelated courses. If you are judged not to have a genuine study purpose, the application may be refused.

What should you do if a job offer asks you to pay a fee first?

Stop payment and check: look up the company through official channels and contact its HR department using a phone number or address you found yourself, not the details in the letter. Real companies do not charge the people they hire in order to give them a job.

What should you do if you gave false information in a past visa application?

Get advice from a lawyer or registered immigration adviser in that country on how to clarify the information with the immigration authority. Dealing with it proactively usually has lighter consequences than being found out, and keeps your future applications from carrying on the inconsistency.

Need specific advice for your case?

We will contact you within 24 hours.

Request consultation now

Related articles

Need more help?

Leave your details and we will get back to you within 24 hours.